Subject: new review for KoDi2009 paper 28
From: KoDi2009 <[email-masked]>
To: Akira Imada <[email-masked]>
Date: Fri, 10 Jul 2009 01:23:08 +0100

PAPER: 28
TITLE: A computational investigation of the optical biosensor by dimensionless model
AUTHORS: (anonymous) 

PC MEMBER: Akira Imada
 
OVERALL RATING: 2 (priimti) 
REVIEWER'S CONFIDENCE: 2 (medium) 
TEMOS  MOKSLINĖ SVARBA: 7 (tikrai priimti)
ORIGINALUMAS: 6 (priimti)
PATEIKIMO KOKYBĖ: 5 (gal priimti)
MEDŽIAGOS DĖSTYMO AIŠKUMAS: 5 (gal priimti)
AR PAVADINIMAS ATITINKA TURINĮ?: 2 (taip)
AR SANTRAUKA ATITINKA STRAIPSNIO TURINĮ?: 2 (taip)
AR TENKINA MOKSLINIO STRAIPSNIO REIKALAVIMUS (T.Y. AR STRAIPSNYJE YRA MOKSLO DARBAMS BŪDINGOS DALYS: ĮVADAS, NURODOMAS TYRIMO TIKSLAS, APTARTAS NAGRINĖJAMOS PROBLEMOS IŠTIRTUMO LAIPSNIS, OBJEKTAS, METODAI, GAUTI REZULTATAI, IŠVADOS ARBA APIBENDRINIMA: 3 (taip)
AR TINKAMOS NUORODOS Į LITERATŪRĄ IR AR JŲ PAKANKA?: 2 (taip)
 
----------------------- REVIEW --------------------

(1) Author wrote "We applied a uniform discrete grid to simulate the biosensor using the implicit finite difference method." What is a uniform discrete grid? Is this assumed every reader knows the term? What is the implicit finite difference method? This should be explicitly explained or refer to the literature. (2) Also, a comparison between simulation and experiment with real biosensor should be included if any, or should be suggested at least. 

----------------- REMARKS FOR PROGRAMME COMMITTEE ------------

Despite the organizers' intention, we can identify authers from, e.g., "... has been presented in previous <sic> work (Baronas et al., 2007)."