Review

Overall rating:

Strong Reject:
Reject: I will argue against this paper
Weak Reject: Vote reject, but won't object
Neutral: Not impressed, won't object
Weak Accept: Vote accept, but won't object
Accept: I will argue for this paper
Strong Accept: Award quality

Originality:

Strong Reject:
Reject: I will argue against this paper
Weak Reject: Vote reject, but won't object
Neutral: Not impressed, won't object
Weak Accept: Vote accept, but won't object
Accept: I will argue for this paper
Strong Accept: Award quality

Significance of topic:

Strong Reject:
Reject: I will argue against this paper
Weak Reject: Vote reject, but won't object
Neutral: Not impressed, won't object
Weak Accept: Vote accept, but won't object
Accept: I will argue for this paper
Strong Accept: Award quality

Technical quality:

Strong Reject:
Reject: I will argue against this paper
Weak Reject: Vote reject, but won't object
Neutral: Not impressed, won't object
Weak Accept: Vote accept, but won't object
Accept: I will argue for this paper
Strong Accept: Award quality

Relevance to Baltic DB&IS:

Strong Reject:
Reject: I will argue against this paper
Weak Reject: Vote reject, but won't object
Neutral: Not impressed, won't object
Weak Accept: Vote accept, but won't object
Accept: I will argue for this paper
Strong Accept: Award quality

Presentation:

Strong Reject:
Reject: I will argue against this paper
Weak Reject: Vote reject, but won't object
Neutral: Not impressed, won't object
Weak Accept: Vote accept, but won't object
Accept: I will argue for this paper
Strong Accept: Award quality

Referee's expertise on the topic

High
Medium
Low

Amount of rewriting required

High
Medium
Low

Optional: Which of the following session(s) would be the most appropriate for this paper?
We use these suggestions in assigning papers to sessions for the conference, but not in determining whether the paper is accepted)

Data and Knowledge Management (Research)
Data Integration Methods (Research)
Data Mining (Research)
Database Technology and Semantic Web (Research)
Distributed Databases (Research)
Information Systems and Security (Research)
Information Systems Integration (Research)
Information Systems, Mobile Computing, and Agents (Research)
Integrated Information Systems (Research)
Knowledge Engineering and Databases (Research)
Linguistic Components of Information Systems (Research)
Logic and Databases (Research)
Ontologies and Concept-Based Search (Research)
Ontology Design and Learning (Research)
Ontology-Based Information Systems (Research)
Querying OWL (Research)
Requirements Engineering for Information Systems (Research)
Semantic Annotation and Semantic Interoperability (Research)
Service Oriented Information Systems (Research)
Service-Oriented Information System Analysis and Design (Research)
Business Information Systems (Application)
Component-Based Systems Development (Application)
Database Development Tools (Application)
E-government and E-commerce (Application)
Geographic Information Systems (Application)
Information Systems and AI Technologies (Application)
Integrated and Interoperable Database Technologies (Application)
National Information Infrastructure Development (Application)
Ontology-enabled Information Retrieval (Application)
RDF Databases (Application)
Semantic Technologies for Information Systems (Application)
Service Oriented Architectures (Application)
Web Information Systems (Application)

Comments for the Program Committee
confidencial comments for PC use only

Comments for the Authors
Constructive comments to the author(s) would be appreciated.

Main contributions

Positive aspects

Negative aspects

Further comments

Email me a copy of this review

Useful for your own record or in case there is some kind of error during updating. Note that if your session times out, you will not receive an email; instead you should log back in right away to recover the review.

I have completed the review

Check this box when you are done reviewing this paper. This is used only to track how many outstanding reviews there are. You will still be able to edit this review after checking this box, until review submission is closed.

[ Submit Review Button ]

Before submitting your review, consider printing it out and copying/pasting the descriptive text fields to a text document. This way, in case of a network/system problem, you will have all the information if it needs to be re-entered.

Should your session timeout while filling out this review, log back in right away as we may be able to recover your review.